刑法 法條競合/想像競合 - 考試
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/00883/0088314a2e4a87aa9b73ceeadd4161731ee08669" alt="Carolina Franco avatar"
By Carolina Franco
at 2013-06-07T01:11
at 2013-06-07T01:11
Table of Contents
應該是考古題,但實在找不到出處,
來源是這裡的23題。
http://tw.myblog.yahoo.com/danhill1127/article?mid=382
甲竊取乙之彰化銀行提款卡,持至該銀行自動櫃員機提款,
得款新台幣五萬元。請問:依據我國刑法之規定及實務之見解,
甲之行為應如何處斷?
(A)甲之行為該當第三百二十條竊盜罪與第三百三十九條之二
自動付款設備詐欺罪,應成立想像競合,從竊盜罪之重罪處斷
(B)甲之行為該當第三百二十條竊盜罪與第三百三十九條之二
自動付款設備詐欺罪,應成立牽連犯,從竊盜罪之重罪處斷
(C)甲之行為該當第三百二十條竊盜罪與第三百三十九條之二
自動付款設備詐欺罪,應成立法條競合,優先適用竊盜罪
(D)甲之行為該當第三百二十條竊盜罪與第三百三十九條之二
自動付款設備詐欺罪,應成立法條競合,優先適用自動付款設備詐欺罪
這題當時考選部給的答案是B,
不過現在牽連犯已經刪除哩~那應該是A還是C呢?
網路上唯一找到的回答是說想像競合,
http://www.lawspace.com.tw/digiBoard/default.asp?ID=21296
不過跟同學討論後覺得應該是法條競合理面的「與罰的後行為」
因為想像競合是一行為觸犯數法益,這是兩行為,應該不是想像競合。
甲偷提款卡是為了領錢,
後面那個領錢的動作使他前面的竊盜有實益,為與法的後行為,
所以應該是 C法條競合,
請問哪個想法才對呢?
--
Tags:
考試
All Comments
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/41c7e/41c7e98ff08d926309b7c9e1e27d58a1346ac95a" alt="William avatar"
By William
at 2013-06-07T12:56
at 2013-06-07T12:56
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/472ec/472ec5102a381fbd1ba983391a53b7f306507655" alt="Sandy avatar"
By Sandy
at 2013-06-12T06:06
at 2013-06-12T06:06
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a8bb2/a8bb2783c268f1c06299484453838664314ffd4a" alt="Olga avatar"
By Olga
at 2013-06-14T03:04
at 2013-06-14T03:04
Related Posts
96年輔大刑法
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b52ea/b52ea7afc3edcba98e113699e16c8b44ef410c96" alt="Andy avatar"
By Andy
at 2013-06-07T00:40
at 2013-06-07T00:40
電機機械-三相電動機
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a8bb2/a8bb2783c268f1c06299484453838664314ffd4a" alt="Olga avatar"
By Olga
at 2013-06-07T00:39
at 2013-06-07T00:39
刑法酒駕
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/de70c/de70cdcd551a0c346fd47adda0b95347feff7704" alt="Charlie avatar"
By Charlie
at 2013-06-07T00:33
at 2013-06-07T00:33
最近三讀的醉態駕駛法條
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/de70c/de70cdcd551a0c346fd47adda0b95347feff7704" alt="Edith avatar"
By Edith
at 2013-06-07T00:20
at 2013-06-07T00:20
行政法4等選擇比重
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e2d68/e2d683c3fccff0dc8b5722536f268e443a589a79" alt="Quanna avatar"
By Quanna
at 2013-06-07T00:00
at 2013-06-07T00:00