刑訴 99年檢事官考題 - 考試
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5dcfc/5dcfc56846cb4cb09c2f00edbe78aad08f2b13ab" alt="Blanche avatar"
By Blanche
at 2013-07-31T00:05
at 2013-07-31T00:05
Table of Contents
[考題] 國考歷屆考題與考題觀念討論(書裡看到的選這個)請附上想法、出處
甲為里長選舉候選人,見對手來勢洶洶,大事不妙,遂向有選舉權之里民
A1、A2、A3 各送一千元,並約定選舉時一定要把票投給甲,
檢察官據報查獲並將甲上揭犯行起訴,發現甲另有行賄給 A4 要求投其一票之事實,
試問,檢察官該如何處理?
{擬答}
(一)甲為里長選舉候選人,向里民A1、A2、A3、A4行賄,構成實體法上之行賄罪,
為集合犯屬於裁判上一罪,單一被告與單一犯罪事實為單一案件,
在實體法上為一個刑罰權,訴訟法上為一個訴訟客體,不容割裂行使
(二)因此檢察官雖據報查獲並先將甲向里民A1、A2、A3行賄犯行起訴,
但檢察官仍可透過第267條規定使得起訴效力及於甲另行賄給里民A4之犯罪事實,
因此檢察官針對另外行賄部份不需另行起訴,僅需對A4部份函送併案即可
*想請教各位前輩*
書上看到這題解法大致如上所述,但小弟問題在於刑訴267條適用前提不是應該要有
審判不可分跟兩者皆有罪嗎??由法院來判斷才對,為何看很多本解題書針對這題
都不會提到這點呢?都直接以{267條效力所及}解決
--
甲為里長選舉候選人,見對手來勢洶洶,大事不妙,遂向有選舉權之里民
A1、A2、A3 各送一千元,並約定選舉時一定要把票投給甲,
檢察官據報查獲並將甲上揭犯行起訴,發現甲另有行賄給 A4 要求投其一票之事實,
試問,檢察官該如何處理?
{擬答}
(一)甲為里長選舉候選人,向里民A1、A2、A3、A4行賄,構成實體法上之行賄罪,
為集合犯屬於裁判上一罪,單一被告與單一犯罪事實為單一案件,
在實體法上為一個刑罰權,訴訟法上為一個訴訟客體,不容割裂行使
(二)因此檢察官雖據報查獲並先將甲向里民A1、A2、A3行賄犯行起訴,
但檢察官仍可透過第267條規定使得起訴效力及於甲另行賄給里民A4之犯罪事實,
因此檢察官針對另外行賄部份不需另行起訴,僅需對A4部份函送併案即可
*想請教各位前輩*
書上看到這題解法大致如上所述,但小弟問題在於刑訴267條適用前提不是應該要有
審判不可分跟兩者皆有罪嗎??由法院來判斷才對,為何看很多本解題書針對這題
都不會提到這點呢?都直接以{267條效力所及}解決
--
Tags:
考試
All Comments
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4b570/4b57020e4f39332e2acde1617d6d6921d347764b" alt="Frederica avatar"
By Frederica
at 2013-08-01T12:29
at 2013-08-01T12:29
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/de70c/de70cdcd551a0c346fd47adda0b95347feff7704" alt="Poppy avatar"
By Poppy
at 2013-08-04T06:13
at 2013-08-04T06:13
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/82482/8248237a1552bce961b7b0c6b477e86334072df3" alt="William avatar"
By William
at 2013-08-05T11:00
at 2013-08-05T11:00
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/93829/9382947c080b725f57918c9bfab3e61cbb38a7db" alt="Anthony avatar"
By Anthony
at 2013-08-06T13:37
at 2013-08-06T13:37
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f3396/f3396e2f7553f04f1899d33093e0a691aedf10b9" alt="Sandy avatar"
By Sandy
at 2013-08-07T07:44
at 2013-08-07T07:44
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6230d/6230d2b4e846b4b383cadd4666a06abbdc42f4db" alt="Brianna avatar"
By Brianna
at 2013-08-08T01:02
at 2013-08-08T01:02
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/459a9/459a9f55b201f11b79c2c8386ddc61c9175149d4" alt="Gilbert avatar"
By Gilbert
at 2013-08-12T07:12
at 2013-08-12T07:12
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1d36e/1d36edce05785a6ffd9e682c775da74d912915c4" alt="Kumar avatar"
By Kumar
at 2013-08-15T10:03
at 2013-08-15T10:03
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/86008/860083d1e9b94f2cfd04d5415edb5e9239fbfe4d" alt="Tracy avatar"
By Tracy
at 2013-08-15T13:49
at 2013-08-15T13:49
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f04c3/f04c38eba156913335c047085fc84dae38693349" alt="Dorothy avatar"
By Dorothy
at 2013-08-16T12:33
at 2013-08-16T12:33
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/daf3a/daf3a876bc35b9695c0934b96e28d390fe63523d" alt="Jacky avatar"
By Jacky
at 2013-08-18T18:44
at 2013-08-18T18:44
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8a0da/8a0dab579fa452a0210402ac1d3aabbdd8899fa2" alt="Lucy avatar"
By Lucy
at 2013-08-19T15:53
at 2013-08-19T15:53
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/41c7e/41c7e98ff08d926309b7c9e1e27d58a1346ac95a" alt="Ida avatar"
By Ida
at 2013-08-22T21:01
at 2013-08-22T21:01
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a8bb2/a8bb2783c268f1c06299484453838664314ffd4a" alt="Quanna avatar"
By Quanna
at 2013-08-23T19:04
at 2013-08-23T19:04
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b52ea/b52ea7afc3edcba98e113699e16c8b44ef410c96" alt="Rae avatar"
By Rae
at 2013-08-25T00:00
at 2013-08-25T00:00
Related Posts
關於電壓電流
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4b570/4b57020e4f39332e2acde1617d6d6921d347764b" alt="Lucy avatar"
By Lucy
at 2013-07-30T23:47
at 2013-07-30T23:47
請問財稅函授的問題
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b52ea/b52ea7afc3edcba98e113699e16c8b44ef410c96" alt="Liam avatar"
By Liam
at 2013-07-30T22:47
at 2013-07-30T22:47
贈書
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/472ec/472ec5102a381fbd1ba983391a53b7f306507655" alt="Ethan avatar"
By Ethan
at 2013-07-30T22:33
at 2013-07-30T22:33
103年起訓練階段人員不能加入退撫
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1d36e/1d36edce05785a6ffd9e682c775da74d912915c4" alt="Linda avatar"
By Linda
at 2013-07-30T21:42
at 2013-07-30T21:42
考律師執照 得闖兩關
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f04c3/f04c38eba156913335c047085fc84dae38693349" alt="Valerie avatar"
By Valerie
at 2013-07-30T21:30
at 2013-07-30T21:30