刑分 肇事逃逸罪構成要件 - 考試
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e2d68/e2d683c3fccff0dc8b5722536f268e443a589a79" alt="Elizabeth avatar"
By Elizabeth
at 2013-05-25T07:57
at 2013-05-25T07:57
Table of Contents
甲不顧宴後已有醉意,仍執意自行駕車返家,途中行經未設置路燈之道路,
不慎撞及某黑色物體,甲自認是撞到野狗,並未下車查看即加速駛離,
但其實是撞到正欲穿越馬路的行人乙,造成乙重傷。
後甲於下個路口遭警方攔檢,酒測值超標。
問本例甲之行為應如何論處?
這裡我確定的是成立§284I過失傷害罪、§185-3不能安全駕駛罪
但不知道肇事逃逸罪是否成立?
同學是說依原因自由行為,甲不顧醉意仍執意駕車...
應成立§185-4肇事逃逸罪。
以生活經驗來看好像也挺合理,不然大家車禍都別下車查看當作自己撞到狗就好了?
但我研究課本上的說法,「肇事逃逸罪僅處罰故意犯,
行為人對於駕駛交通工具致人死傷之事實須有認識,而有意逃逸者始成罪
若行為人不知其以肇事並致人死傷,縱然逃逸,與本罪之構成要件不合。」
另外有個判決是肇事者下車查看後未發現傷者故離去,
雖事實上致人死傷但因其未有肇逃之故意,故不成立本罪。
依照此說,甲對於致乙重傷並無認識,應不成罪
但無認識的原因是甲"自認"撞到狗而"未下車查看",是否會生其他問題?
如果甲有下車查看,或許就會發現傷者乙了?
--
不慎撞及某黑色物體,甲自認是撞到野狗,並未下車查看即加速駛離,
但其實是撞到正欲穿越馬路的行人乙,造成乙重傷。
後甲於下個路口遭警方攔檢,酒測值超標。
問本例甲之行為應如何論處?
這裡我確定的是成立§284I過失傷害罪、§185-3不能安全駕駛罪
但不知道肇事逃逸罪是否成立?
同學是說依原因自由行為,甲不顧醉意仍執意駕車...
應成立§185-4肇事逃逸罪。
以生活經驗來看好像也挺合理,不然大家車禍都別下車查看當作自己撞到狗就好了?
但我研究課本上的說法,「肇事逃逸罪僅處罰故意犯,
行為人對於駕駛交通工具致人死傷之事實須有認識,而有意逃逸者始成罪
若行為人不知其以肇事並致人死傷,縱然逃逸,與本罪之構成要件不合。」
另外有個判決是肇事者下車查看後未發現傷者故離去,
雖事實上致人死傷但因其未有肇逃之故意,故不成立本罪。
依照此說,甲對於致乙重傷並無認識,應不成罪
但無認識的原因是甲"自認"撞到狗而"未下車查看",是否會生其他問題?
如果甲有下車查看,或許就會發現傷者乙了?
--
Tags:
考試
All Comments
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5dcfc/5dcfc56846cb4cb09c2f00edbe78aad08f2b13ab" alt="Queena avatar"
By Queena
at 2013-05-28T20:28
at 2013-05-28T20:28
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/de70c/de70cdcd551a0c346fd47adda0b95347feff7704" alt="Andy avatar"
By Andy
at 2013-06-02T10:40
at 2013-06-02T10:40
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4b570/4b57020e4f39332e2acde1617d6d6921d347764b" alt="Sarah avatar"
By Sarah
at 2013-06-04T20:46
at 2013-06-04T20:46
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f3396/f3396e2f7553f04f1899d33093e0a691aedf10b9" alt="Bethany avatar"
By Bethany
at 2013-06-05T03:16
at 2013-06-05T03:16
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/82482/8248237a1552bce961b7b0c6b477e86334072df3" alt="Carolina Franco avatar"
By Carolina Franco
at 2013-06-05T04:27
at 2013-06-05T04:27
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6230d/6230d2b4e846b4b383cadd4666a06abbdc42f4db" alt="Candice avatar"
By Candice
at 2013-06-08T07:45
at 2013-06-08T07:45
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1d36e/1d36edce05785a6ffd9e682c775da74d912915c4" alt="Kelly avatar"
By Kelly
at 2013-06-11T00:08
at 2013-06-11T00:08
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/93829/9382947c080b725f57918c9bfab3e61cbb38a7db" alt="Tristan Cohan avatar"
By Tristan Cohan
at 2013-06-11T19:37
at 2013-06-11T19:37
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/86008/860083d1e9b94f2cfd04d5415edb5e9239fbfe4d" alt="Christine avatar"
By Christine
at 2013-06-11T23:09
at 2013-06-11T23:09
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f04c3/f04c38eba156913335c047085fc84dae38693349" alt="Elizabeth avatar"
By Elizabeth
at 2013-06-16T19:19
at 2013-06-16T19:19
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/459a9/459a9f55b201f11b79c2c8386ddc61c9175149d4" alt="Joseph avatar"
By Joseph
at 2013-06-17T22:52
at 2013-06-17T22:52
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8a0da/8a0dab579fa452a0210402ac1d3aabbdd8899fa2" alt="Quintina avatar"
By Quintina
at 2013-06-18T04:11
at 2013-06-18T04:11
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/41c7e/41c7e98ff08d926309b7c9e1e27d58a1346ac95a" alt="Elma avatar"
By Elma
at 2013-06-18T13:43
at 2013-06-18T13:43
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/daf3a/daf3a876bc35b9695c0934b96e28d390fe63523d" alt="David avatar"
By David
at 2013-06-23T04:10
at 2013-06-23T04:10
Related Posts
喪失繼承權
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/472ec/472ec5102a381fbd1ba983391a53b7f306507655" alt="Rachel avatar"
By Rachel
at 2013-05-25T00:13
at 2013-05-25T00:13
民訴解題書
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a8bb2/a8bb2783c268f1c06299484453838664314ffd4a" alt="Callum avatar"
By Callum
at 2013-05-25T00:08
at 2013-05-25T00:08
程式語言問題
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e2d68/e2d683c3fccff0dc8b5722536f268e443a589a79" alt="Lauren avatar"
By Lauren
at 2013-05-24T23:54
at 2013-05-24T23:54
喪失繼承權
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1d36e/1d36edce05785a6ffd9e682c775da74d912915c4" alt="Ethan avatar"
By Ethan
at 2013-05-24T23:13
at 2013-05-24T23:13
工業工程與管理系可考的國考及國營
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6230d/6230d2b4e846b4b383cadd4666a06abbdc42f4db" alt="Rosalind avatar"
By Rosalind
at 2013-05-24T22:54
at 2013-05-24T22:54