身高差1.1公分遭退訓!小隻女「消防夢碎」…二 - 考試
By Odelette
at 2021-12-24T11:31
at 2021-12-24T11:31
Table of Contents
2021年12月23日 20:48
記者閔文昱/綜合報導
陳姓女子2018年考上消防員,卻於中心訓練時,被驗出身高僅158.9公分、不到160遭退訓
,陳女不服、提行政訴訟,台北高等行政法院去年判她勝訴,但公務人員保障暨培訓委員
會(保訓會)上訴後,最高行政法院今(23日)判決,該標準具有合理性,核無濫用裁量
,判陳女敗訴確定。
判決指出,陳女參加2018年「公務人員特種考試一般警察人員考試四等考試消防警察人員
類別考試」獲錄取,並於2019年1月16日至消防署訓練中心報到接受教育訓練,但經該中
心檢測身高後,認有複檢之必要,因此安排到南投醫院進行體格複檢結果,結果發現陳女
身高為158.9公分,未及160公分,不符考試規則所定的身高標準。對此,陳女受訓資格遭
到廢止,她不服提起訴願遭決定駁回,於是提起行政訴訟。一審法官認為,女性消防員身
高160公分的限制,只是沿用先前消防與警察還沒分開時的規定,但消防員與警察碰到的
狀況不同,不能以警察的要求,作為消防員的考選標準,且即使身高較低的人,也能藉由
調整消防器材,讓他們能順利完成任務,認定消防署僅憑陳女身高撤銷訓練資格違憲,判
女勝訴。
保訓會事後上訴最高行政法院,二審法官指出,考試院依公務人員考試法第7條授權訂定
身高限制,是因考量警察人員肩負社會治安維護、捍衛人民生命財產安全重責,應具備一
定標準的體格、體魄與耐力,因此訂定男性身高須165公分以上、女性須160公分以上,目
的是為了維護警消能勝任執行任務,維持勤務功能正常運作,不違反平等原則及比例原則
。
二審法官認為,警消工作勤務態樣危險而複雜多變,各式應勤裝備、器具都有一定的標準
化規格,消防人員如果不能有效操作各項器材及設備、完成任務,將影響緊急救災的時效
,甚至危害使用人員及其他現場人員安全,因此主管機關訂定警消的女性要求身高160公
分以上,標準具有合理性,核無濫用裁量,判決陳女敗訴。全案確定。
網址:
https://www.ettoday.net/amp/amp_news.php7?news_id=2153320&from=fb_et_share
=====
沒有想到後續竟然是敗訴……
--
記者閔文昱/綜合報導
陳姓女子2018年考上消防員,卻於中心訓練時,被驗出身高僅158.9公分、不到160遭退訓
,陳女不服、提行政訴訟,台北高等行政法院去年判她勝訴,但公務人員保障暨培訓委員
會(保訓會)上訴後,最高行政法院今(23日)判決,該標準具有合理性,核無濫用裁量
,判陳女敗訴確定。
判決指出,陳女參加2018年「公務人員特種考試一般警察人員考試四等考試消防警察人員
類別考試」獲錄取,並於2019年1月16日至消防署訓練中心報到接受教育訓練,但經該中
心檢測身高後,認有複檢之必要,因此安排到南投醫院進行體格複檢結果,結果發現陳女
身高為158.9公分,未及160公分,不符考試規則所定的身高標準。對此,陳女受訓資格遭
到廢止,她不服提起訴願遭決定駁回,於是提起行政訴訟。一審法官認為,女性消防員身
高160公分的限制,只是沿用先前消防與警察還沒分開時的規定,但消防員與警察碰到的
狀況不同,不能以警察的要求,作為消防員的考選標準,且即使身高較低的人,也能藉由
調整消防器材,讓他們能順利完成任務,認定消防署僅憑陳女身高撤銷訓練資格違憲,判
女勝訴。
保訓會事後上訴最高行政法院,二審法官指出,考試院依公務人員考試法第7條授權訂定
身高限制,是因考量警察人員肩負社會治安維護、捍衛人民生命財產安全重責,應具備一
定標準的體格、體魄與耐力,因此訂定男性身高須165公分以上、女性須160公分以上,目
的是為了維護警消能勝任執行任務,維持勤務功能正常運作,不違反平等原則及比例原則
。
二審法官認為,警消工作勤務態樣危險而複雜多變,各式應勤裝備、器具都有一定的標準
化規格,消防人員如果不能有效操作各項器材及設備、完成任務,將影響緊急救災的時效
,甚至危害使用人員及其他現場人員安全,因此主管機關訂定警消的女性要求身高160公
分以上,標準具有合理性,核無濫用裁量,判決陳女敗訴。全案確定。
網址:
https://www.ettoday.net/amp/amp_news.php7?news_id=2153320&from=fb_et_share
=====
沒有想到後續竟然是敗訴……
--
Tags:
考試
All Comments
By Elizabeth
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Zora
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Annie
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Daph Bay
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Kama
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Mary
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Erin
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Catherine
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Mary
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Olga
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Tracy
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Valerie
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Joseph
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Belly
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Caitlin
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Agatha
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Lydia
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Leila
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Hedy
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Rachel
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Eartha
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Wallis
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Olive
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Puput
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Olga
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Una
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Callum
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Sierra Rose
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Agatha
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Carol
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Caitlin
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Annie
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Valerie
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Andrew
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Mia
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Ida
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Margaret
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Edith
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Brianna
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Margaret
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Thomas
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Olive
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Rae
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Joe
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Doris
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Charlie
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Margaret
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Faithe
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Emma
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Faithe
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Ina
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Brianna
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Oscar
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Rebecca
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Gilbert
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Agnes
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By David
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Adele
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Lucy
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Lauren
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Cara
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Megan
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Skylar Davis
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By David
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Leila
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Zora
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Hamiltion
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By William
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Lucy
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Jack
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Sierra Rose
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Wallis
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Zora
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By James
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Catherine
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Charlie
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Sandy
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Adele
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
By Annie
at 2021-12-23T08:18
at 2021-12-23T08:18
By Callum
at 2021-12-27T00:32
at 2021-12-27T00:32
Related Posts
高雄學廬失火
By Freda
at 2021-12-24T10:17
at 2021-12-24T10:17
110年地特三等考試-人事行政
By Wallis
at 2021-12-24T00:59
at 2021-12-24T00:59
民法227條2項與227-1的關係 101律師舉例
By Kristin
at 2021-12-23T19:59
at 2021-12-23T19:59
初等考 公民 一題選擇題請教
By Daph Bay
at 2021-12-23T19:46
at 2021-12-23T19:46
一題會計
By Ursula
at 2021-12-23T16:45
at 2021-12-23T16:45